Echinacea...Miracle or Fraud?

The only dramatic difference between Sam's Formula and other antioxidant formulas is the Echinacea, which is the base of Sam's Formula. Many of our members believe that Echinacea base contributes greatly to the apparent miracles. The following is presented in order to inform you about this mysterious herb.
The following is taken from the Australian Journal of Medical Herbalism, vol 4 (4) 1992. This is a scientific journal which accepts no product advertisements.

History of Echinacea

Echinacea was first discovered in the late 18th century in use by native Americans in the plains states. They used it for all internal and external infections. It was their sole option for snake bite. (Cancer was unknown among these Indians)

In 1887, Dr. H.C.F. Meyer introduced Echinacea in the form of Meyer's Blood Purifier. He made extravagant claims for his product. The back label read: "Take one ounce three times every day in the following causes: rhumatism, sick headaches, dyspepsia, old sores and bites, open wounds, dizziness and scrofula. In case of poisoning take the double dose, and for bites of rattlesnakes take three ounces three times a day until swelling is gone. This is a absolute cure within 24 hours." At this time some scoundrels claimed their product brought dead people back to life.

Echinacea gained great popularity early this century until the February 27, 1908 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) in which an editorial discredited Echinacea. In the November 1909 issue of JAMA an article was published titled, "Echinacea considered valuless".

Pharmacology of Echinacea

Echinacoside has an interferon-like activity. It has mild antibiotic activity against Streptococcus and Staphylococcus aureus. Six mg. echinacoside is equivalent to one unit of penicillin. Oncolytic activities (destructive to tumor cells) have been attributed to the volitile oils of Echinacea. Echinacea may be more effective as an anitbiotic than cortisone ie 0.04 ml. of fresh plant extract possesses a hyaluronidase inhibitory action equal to 1 mg. of cortisone. Indications: Stress, harsh environments or seasons, or whenever the body is in need of reinforcement. Echinacea may supply the boost required to maintain the natural lines of resistance to mend injured tissue and to stimulate body functioning.

Experimental Studies In 1984 by H. Wagner et al studied purified polysaccharides (EPS) from echinacea purpurea. It was observed that they strongly activated macrophages. These macrophages developed pronounced extracellular cytotoxicity against tumor cells.

In 1991 German researchers found that mice (fed Echinacea) were protected against otherwise lethal infections.

Clinical Studies

In 1985 a study found that Echinacea stimulates the production of white blood cells in the bone marrow of patients undergoing radiology treatment.

1986 a double blind study of 203 patients with vaginal candida revealed that Echinacea was three times more effective than conventional methods.
Get a 1 oz. vial of liquid Echinacea from your health food store. Put it on any cut of skin infection and be prepared for a miracle within 48 hours.

A myth is circulating that continued use of Echinacea causes loss of efficacy. It came from a mistranslation of an article published in German. See Medical Herbalism, Spring 1994.

Return to menu.